1 of 1 people found this review helpful
Amazing World building; Lacks in Other Parts
8 March, 2014
Since reading Diana Peterfreud's For Darkness Shows The Stars, I've been slightly apprehensive about retellings. I found For Darkness Shows The Stars having WAY too many things similar to Persuasion, which, in my opinion, detracted from the originality of the story (I did find Across The Star Swept Sea to be much better, though), and I was scared that the same would be true with Cruel Beauty.
Fortunately, I was never more wrong about anything.
While Hodge may have picked the bare bones from Beauty & the Beast, that's about all she's taken from it. The most important distinction from the original is that both Nyx (Beauty) and Ignifex (Beast) are fundamentally flawed characters. Nyx fights everyday with her bitter feelings towards her father, who was so willing to give her up, her aunt, who attempts to assume her mother's place, her dead mother, for being so weak, and her sister, Astraia, whom she both loves and resents terribly. Yeah, that's a lot of hate to lug around. But you know what? That was something I really loved about this story: how both our star crossed lovers recognize the darkness that resides within them, acknowledge it, embrace it even, and pursue their desires with the full knowledge that they do not deserve it.
Ignifex was a rather confusing character for me. Save for his actions in the past, I honestly did not not find him 'beastly' at all. In fact, while he may appear a little Voldemort like (slitted pupils make a return), he is not half as vicious as him, as far as his conduct in the book is concerned. But, when weighed against his history, he does come out looking the villain.
And when a villain like Ignifex and a girl like Nyx fall in love... That is the crux of the story. Do you judge a person by their past actions or their present conduct? Is it right to hold such cruelty in a heart? Do hearts so filled with darkness deserve to taste the sweet nectar of love and a happy ending? Are they capable of the higher human principles like altruism and self sacrifice, and if they are, is the denial just what they deserve, or have they proved themselves worthy of happiness? I can keep plumbing the depths of this story and keep coming up with more such philosophical ponderings, but I think I've conveyed my point.
However, as you must have gleaned from my 3.5 rating for Cruel Beauty, there were a few glitches that the book could have done without. For one, the complexity of the plot has a possible downside to it as well, in that readers may lose track of what is going on at any particular moment (it happened to me and I had to backtrack a couple of times). For another, the plot progression does not occur at a consistent pace, resulting in flurries of happenings in between long periods of virtually nothing. And given that Ignifex appears only infrequently in the first half of the book, we spend a lot of time in Nyx's head, which can become tiring after a while (I admit, I skimmed). Cruel Beauty is also home to a very unusual love triangle. I normally cannot abide love triangles, but admittedly, the one in this tale has plays a vital role, so I can forgive its presence. It also falls into the trap of insta-love, which, fortunately, is offset (only slightly, though) by the almost painfully sweet moments between Ignifex and Nyx, when the learn more of each other and become true friends.
Cruel Beauty does not read like the work of a debutante. The writing has the feel of a fairy tale to it, in perfect sync with the theme of the book. Hodge's brilliant imagery gives rise to one of the most visually marvelous worlds I've encountered in the fictional realm. While the central plot is a parallel to Beauty & The Beast, it appears that the author has also incorporated aspects of other fairy tales into the story (only in tiny bits, though), brought in at the prefect moments, so that although the underlying concept is old, she has made it her own. Readers who are interested in Greek mythology will enjoy Cruel Beauty, for it is steeped in it, and is no doubt a contributing factor to the otherworldly mood the book evokes.
Bottomline: While Cruel Beauty has it's dull moments, it's nevertheless a tale of self discovery and the extent to which true love can go that leaves you questioning your ideals. A perfect example of a retelling if I've ever seen one!
Problem in saving your vote. Try again.